Summerland Key Homes for Sale


Nestled in the heart of the Lower Florida Keys, Summerland Key offers a unique blend of island tranquility, waterfront living, and easy access to some of the region’s most sought-after recreational opportunities.


This charming residential community offers a relaxed atmosphere, stunning natural surroundings, and an exceptional boating lifestyle. Located approximately 25 miles from Key West along the iconic Overseas Highway, Summerland Key is characterized by quiet streets, tropical landscaping, and a welcoming neighborhood feel that appeals to full-time residents, seasonal homeowners, and investors alike.


With direct access to both the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico, Summerland Key is a favorite locale for anglers, divers, boaters, and anyone seeking the authentic Florida Keys experience. Despite its peaceful setting, the island remains conveniently close to the dining, shopping, and entertainment options of Key West and Marathon.


Summerland Key real estate features an impressive selection of properties designed to embrace island living. Buyers can choose from modern canal-front homes with private docks, spacious 2,500+ square feet multi-family residences, and modern single-family homes.


Properties often include sought-after amenities such as deep-water dockage, swimming pools, expansive outdoor entertaining areas, and direct boating access to the surrounding waters.


Whether you're searching for a primary residence, vacation retreat, or investment property, Summerland Key offers an unmatched opportunity to enjoy the beauty, privacy, and lifestyle that make the Florida Keys one of the most desirable coastal destinations in the world.


FL

Summerland Key

Average Sales Price
$2,498,131
Median Sales Price
$1,250,000
Total Listings
32
Population Data provided by Attom Data
4,473

Discover Summerland Key Real Estate: Homes for Sale in a Tranquil Florida Keys Paradise

Summerland Key, nestled in the Lower Florida Keys, is the ideal destination for those seeking a peaceful island lifestyle.


Known for its tranquil surroundings and convenient access to open water, Summerland Key real estate offers a variety of stunning properties for every type of buyer. From waterfront estates to charming island-style homes, homes on Summerland Key offer the perfect blend of relaxation and investment potential.


Why Live in Summerland Key?

Living in Summerland Key means embracing a peaceful, nature-filled lifestyle, surrounded by crystal-clear waters and lush tropical landscapes. Perfectly positioned for easy access to surrounding islands, including Middle and Little Torch Keys, Ramrod Key, and Cudjoe Key, you’ll find no shortage of white sand beaches and turquoise waters to enjoy.


With its quiet residential areas and easy access to the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico, Summerland Key is a prime location for boating, fishing, and other water-based activities. It’s the perfect place for those who want to enjoy the laid-back atmosphere of the Florida Keys while still being close to amenities in nearby Key West and Marathon.


The island offers a serene environment with a strong sense of community. So, whether you're looking for a permanent residence or a vacation home, Summerland Key provides the perfect backdrop for island living.


Summerland Key Real Estate Market

The Summerland Key real estate market is highly attractive due to its peaceful ambiance, stunning waterfront views, and proximity to world-class fishing and diving spots.


Whether you're searching for a luxurious oceanfront estate, a cozy canal-front home, or a vacation rental property, the variety of Summerland Key homes for sale ensures that you’ll find the perfect match for your needs.

When browsing Summerland Key real estate, you’ll discover:

  • Waterfront homes with private docks, perfect for boaters and anglers
  • Island-style cottages with tropical charm and modern amenities
  • Luxury estates with expansive views of the Atlantic or Gulf
  • Investment properties that are ideal for seasonal rentals or year-round living


Maximize Your Property Investment with Vacation Rentals

Investing in Summerland Key real estate is not only about enjoying the island life but also about generating income through vacation rentals.


The peaceful setting of Summerland Key attracts visitors looking for a tranquil escape, making it an excellent location for short-term vacation rentals.


To optimize your investment, consider working with a professional vacation rental management service like Coco Plum Vacation Rentals. Our expert team will manage everything from marketing your property to ensuring top-notch guest experiences, allowing you to enjoy a steady rental income while keeping your property in pristine condition.


Summerland Key Homes for Every Lifestyle

Whether you're searching for a family-friendly home, a private retreat, or an investment opportunity, Summerland Key homes cater to a variety of preferences. From quiet neighborhoods surrounded by lush vegetation to stunning waterfront properties with direct access to the ocean, there’s something for everyone on this peaceful island in the heart of Monroe County.


Summerland Real Estate & Homes For Sale

With its scenic surroundings, peaceful atmosphere, and strong real estate market, Summerland Key is an ideal location for homebuyers and investors alike. Owning a home in Summerland Key allows you to experience the beauty and tranquility of the Florida Keys while also providing an opportunity to generate rental income.


Start exploring Summerland Key homes for sale today and find the perfect property to match your lifestyle and investment goals. Whether you’re looking for a primary residence, a vacation home, or a rental property, Summerland Key offers endless possibilities. Partner with a trusted Florida Keys realty group like Coco Plum Vacation Rentals to ensure your property reaches its full potential as a lucrative vacation rental.


Contact a trusted Summerland Key real estate agent today for new listings, open houses, and virtual tours, and take the first step toward owning your own piece of paradise in the Florida Keys.

RECENTLY SOLD

MORE LISTINGS

Image

Address

Sold Date

Property Type

Configuration

Price

housing detail

Occupancy
Data provided by Attom Data

Coming Soon

Listing Detail

Attributes Average Median
Bathrooms 2.32 2
Bedrooms 3 3
Year Built 1997 1999
Lot Size 27,074 Sqft 7,945 Sqft
Taxes $9,901 $7,419

Nearby Locations

PROPERTIESSCHOOLSBUSINESS
School and business data provided by Attom Data.

Commute Score

Data provided by Attom Data
Coming Soon
Temperature (°F)
Data provided by Attom Data

Coming Soon

demographics

Data provided by Attom Data

Population

4.5K
4.5K in 2020

Density

35.7
per square mile

Households

2.1K
17% with children

Gender

Coming Soon

Education

10% Associate
20% Bachelor
13% Graduate
28% High School
Age Median:

Coming Soon

Annual Income Average:

Coming Soon

Employment

Coming Soon

Kelly Willey

Kelly Willey

Broker | License ID: BK3084960

+1(305) 432-9754

GET MORE INFORMATION

Full Name
Phone*
Message
Kelly Willey

Kelly Willey

Broker | License ID: BK3084960

+1(305) 432-9754

Full Name
Phone*